We get asked a lot about what makes us different from our competitors. So we decided to take an honest look at some of our competitors to show you how we stack up and tell you about the Car Stickers difference. When shopping for custom stickers, you’ll see a few big names pop up over and over: Sticker Mule, StickerYou, and StickerApp to name a few. But how do they really stack up against Car Stickers? Here’s a breakdown by company.
Company Comparisons
Car Stickers l Best Overall
- Over 70 vinyl materials. Industry leader in transfer decals.
- No minimum order requirements.
- Free shipping.
- Multiple backing options available: Kiss Cut, Die Cut, Split Backing.
- Fast Turnaround. Option to skip proof so artwork goes straight to production.
- Bulk discounts and competitive everyday pricing.
- Excellent design tool for easy customization.
Sticker Mule
- Fast turnaround and free shipping.
- Simple ordering process.
- Robust online editor for custom designs.
- Regular deals and promotions available.
Weaknesses: Transfer decals only available in black and white. Premium pricing compared to competitors. Minimum order quantities of 10 stickers for most materials.
StickerYou
- Variety of roll label options and unique custom products like temporary tattoos.
- Shipping estimates on every page.
- Easy to read information and resources about materials on every page.
- No minimum order quantities.
Weaknesses: Pricing can get expensive. Variety of products require quote i.e. vinyl window graphics (transfer window decals).
StickerApp
- Unique materials like holographic, mirror, and glow-in-the-dark.
- Glossy, matte, or cracked ice compatible laminates.
- Back printing available.
- Quick turnaround.
Weaknesses: Minimum order quantities vary depending on material. Limited shipping options.
Sticky Brand
- Premium materials and durability, featuring their trademark “bombproof” vinyl.
- Good customization options.
- Consistent deals, promotions and rewards program for customer savings.
- Ability to surpass proof for quicker turnaround.
Weaknesses: Minimum order quantities of 100. Transfer decals only available in black.
Sticker Giant
- Great option for roll labels with a wide variety of label options.
- Streamlined ordering process and regular coupons.
- Split backing available on most materials for easier peel.
- Customer support with useful artwork setup guides and resources online.
Weaknesses: Minimum order quantities and higher prices.
Make Stickers
- Transparent shipping times.
- Split backing on stickers.
- Streamlined ordering process.
- No minimums.
Weaknesses: Limited material options. Limited customization option in design tool.
Sticker Junkie
- In business since 1999.
- Option for proof or no proof to streamline process.
- Option of matte or gloss lamination.
- Free shipping.
Weaknesses: Minimum order quantity of 50. "Sticker Generator" has limited customization options. Limited material resources online.
Vinyl Disorder
- Large decal library of designs.
- High-quality vinyl.
- Promotions and deals regularly available.
- Variety of specialty vinyl materials and lamination to choose from like cracked ice.
Weaknesses: Minimum order quantity of 25. No design tool.
Papaya Stickers
- Website is easy to navigate.
- Promotions and deals regularly available.
- Economy stickers available for a more affordable option.
- Free shipping.
Weaknesses: Minimum order quantity of 25. Newer presence online, unsure how long they have been in the industry.
Standard White Vinyl Comparison
When we talk about sticker suppliers, it’s important to note that not all of our competitors use the same vinyl that we do. We took the most popular sticker—standard white vinyl—and did a comparison table with everyone so that you don’t have to. This way, when you compare us to our competitors, you will know if it is an apples-to-apples comparison or not.
Different materials have specific use cases that make them better or worse for certain projects. It’s important to think about what you need the stickers for to choose the right type of vinyl.
| Company | Standard Sticker | Finishing | Price for 100 (3"x3") | Free Shipping |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Car Stickers | White Vinyl | Gloss or Matte Vinyl Lamination | $63 | ✔ |
| Make Stickers | White BOPP | Glossy PET or Matte BOPP | $89.15 | ✔ |
| Papaya Stickers | White Vinyl | Vinyl Lamination | $65.98 | ✔ |
| Sticker App | White Polypropylene PP | PET finish (Gloss, Matte, Cracked Ice) | $71 | ✔ |
| Sticky Brand | White “Bombproof” Vinyl | UV Protective Laminate | $67.50 | X |
| Sticker Giant | White BOPP | Laminate Coating | $103 | ✔ |
| Sticker Junkie | White Vinyl | Gloss or Matte Lamination | $100 | ✔ |
| Sticker Mule | White Vinyl | Matte Vinyl Lamination Only | $94 | ✔ |
| Sticker You | White Vinyl | Semi Gloss Lamination Only | $81.52 | X |
| Vinyl Disorder | White Vinyl | Vinyl Lamination (various finishes) | $64.50 | X |
Vinyl, PET, and BOPP each have unique strengths depending on their intended use. Vinyl lasts 2–7+ years, especially when laminated, making it ideal for outdoor use. PET works well for mid-term indoor/outdoor use but isn’t as long-lasting as vinyl. BOPP is most commonly used for indoor labeling and has the shortest lifespan of the three.
Final Thoughts
Each of these competitors has something to offer, but Car Stickers gives you the best mix of variety, value, and customer-first service. We’ve been in the sticker business for over 25 years. We ship all over the U.S. and world and have worked hard to create a user-friendly website and design tool to empower customers to create inspired designs. Our production and processing teams continuously works to improve our processes so you receive high-quality stickers as quickly as possible. Some of our differentiators include:
- 70+ materials, from glitter to glow to real wood veneer
- High-quality standard vinyl with free matte or gloss lamination
- Free shipping on all orders
- Members of 1% for the Planet
- No order minimums
- Competitive pricing & bulk discounts
- Decades of experience and strong reviews
Are you ready to order some custom stickers but don't know where to start? Check out our samples page to test out different materials. Or start designing custom stickers today!
